Stimulating sprawl

Lawrence Solomon
4 Apr 2009
National Post

Sprawl in Toronto just got its biggest boost in 50 years, thanks to Ontario Premier Dalton McGuinty's decision this week to stimulate the economy through a $9-billion spending spree on transportation infrastructure. Look for Toronto to bust out all over - North, East and West - in line with the major routes he promises to fund. And look for low-density sprawl to spread to Toronto's detriment, just as occurred with the uneconomic transportation infrastructure built in the past.

Fifty years ago, the big impetus to sprawl was the creation of Metropolitan Toronto, a melding of a viable Toronto with its struggling suburbs. Among the legacies of Metro was the financial destruction of the Toronto Transportation Commission, then the premier transit system in North America. Before Metro's creation, all of Toronto's public transit routes were robust and profitable. Upon Metro's creation, the TTC's profitable routes were bled in an attempt to provide transit service to the unprofitable low-density suburbs. Soon, virtually all of the TTC's routes, in both city and suburb, became unprofitable, and the city, too, fell on hard times.

Metro's ruinous expansion of transportation infrastructure included an expressway network that was abruptly halted with one major component, the Spadina Expressway, half built. Another major component in an even earlier state of construction - the Crosstown Expressway - was likewise halted (Toronto residents will recognize the only part that was built as what now appears to be a seemingly endless interchange connecting the Don Valley Parkway to Bayview Avenue and Bloor Street).

Now the Crosstown is back, a few miles north of the original Crosstown route and recast as a light-rail road, rather than as an automobile expressway. Like the original, this express route, now called the Eglinton Crosstown Rapid Transit line, is divorced from the needs of riders - the minimal traffic to be carried can justify perhaps one-tenth of its estimated $4.6-billion expense. The rest is waste.

McGuinty's justification for the line is neither need nor profitability, but "shovel-ready projects" and "economic stimulus." In this he is not alone: Governments throughout the continent are shovelling money as fast as they can, largely into low- or no-value infrastructure projects that have never had either the financing or the customer demand to proceed. With wasteful government spending now seen as a virtue, all restraints are off, particularly since much of the spending is also justified on environmental grounds. Along with unneeded transit and roads, we're seeing unneeded windmills and other green power plants, and the unneeded power grids to support them.

In the government's thinking, the immense cost of this stimulus spending, and the decades of indebtedness it brings, is justified by an immediate benefit to the economy and a long-term benefit to the environment. But the consequences to the environment are often negative, not positive, even with seemingly praiseworthy projects such as public transit.

This was the case with Metropolitan government 50 years ago, when subsidized public transit and other infrastructure fuelled the growth of the modern suburb, and this was also the case almost 100 years ago, when public transit played a dominant role in the creation of Toronto's older suburbs.

Until the 1920s, Toronto's suburbs were viable - small, self-supporting communities that had developed on the basis of local agriculture or some other local industry. Transit to the suburbs - at the time provided by a profit-oriented private sector - was minimal, in keeping with the minimal demand. Then Toronto's municipal government asked the private sector to operate unprofitable routes to the suburbs and, when it refused, took over the private company and bent transit services to its will. The suburbs soon over-expanded, became financially insolvent and, when tough economic times came in the 1920s and 1930s, they became derelict and most became bankrupt, leading the province to take over their financial affairs.

Dereliction is also a consequence for Toronto of sprawling suburbs. City taxes must rise to provide services for those in the suburbs who use city roads and other city services; city taxes must then rise again as businesses and residents flee the tax burden in the city, leaving those behind with higher tax burdens. City governors, meanwhile, cut back on services to fend off a tax revolt. It is this vicious cycle that leads to the hollowing out of cities.

Preceding every hollowing out, we hear hollow words. This week, we heard Premier McGuinty announcing "the most ambitious project of its kind in Canadian history" and promising that more money would come.

Lawrence Solomon is executive director of Energy Probe and Urban Renaissance Institute, and author of Toronto Sprawls.

For fall 2010, the

For fall 2010, the Affliction clothing style is still in the forefront. Art & characterized deconstructed attitude, custom washed pieces embellished with the best equipment & finishes. affliction shirts & sweatshirts with dramatic, hand-illustrated, highly stylized, hard-edged designs have become the hallmark of the line. On behalf of the struggle between lovely & disagreeable, the pieces of rock & roll constantly push the envelope when it comes to images & design, while maintaining the highest sense of fashion appeal. The sinful clothing brand quickly became a household name thanks to its giant celebrity following that includes a Listers, rock bands & athletes. Affliction

Rosetta Stone Spanish is a popular course that has been around for many years. They claim that it has been used with great success by venerable government agencies such as the US State Department and NASA. Rosetta Stone French is a unique learn French software program that can teach you French without the need to write anything down or take any notes. It uses a teaching technique that I believe is unique to Rosetta Stone….

I know Tiffany Jewelry is very successful in the international. As a famous jewelry brand, Tiffany has been ranked at the top position of jewelry brands. The unique designs and fashionable styles make Tiffany Rings far exceed the other top luxury jewelry brands. It’s a wise choice for you to choose Tiffany jewelry as your favorite jewelry brand. Its designs and qualities will never let down. So many fashion Tiffany Necklaces will be never out of date.

UGG has set a boot sensation all over the world. People of any age and profession are getting fascinated with these sheepskin boot styles from the land down under. Historically, Ugg Boots were firstly worn by shepherds for protection from the inclement weather. However, it is believed that these flat soled fur-lined boots have made it into the cutting edge fashion world since war pilots wear these boots to keep their feet warm in high altitudes as well as the surfers use Ugg Short to warm up their feet after a chilly dip into the ocean. Undeniably, Ugg Shortstyles relive worldwide people' s hidden passion for casual comfort and style in ultimate.

Ralph Lauren Polo Shirts was the first brand that came into being and was recognized very well in the market as people used to admire the way they turned ordinary clothing into contemporary apparels. This was made exclusively for men and by far, the Burberry Polo shirts is the most widely produced of the entire lineup. These are perfectly tailored Ralph Lauren Polo Shirts and other apparels ranging from sports wears to leather outfits. polo shirts Sale outlets are around the world and you can even catch up with your favorite apparels through the online store.

sale-handbags

Over a century Bulgari was in the forefront of Italian luxury .Its origin was in 1884. Adoration of the Ultimate in Greek and Roman art is the real power behind it .Bulgari was the father of this brand .He was Greek by birth who imbibed the Roman culture .Its brand name stands as a synonym for luxury. World over celebrities decorated their wrists with replica watches and ornaments .This was imitated by the masses.The Jewelry house Gucci replica making in the early years of twentieth century. The BlancPain replica watches brand gained fame at the end of the same century .The architect of this Bell & Ross replica really wished to make a unique signature for the Breitling replica with the classic qualities seen on the eminent replica Maurice Lacroix .They successfully engraved the motto on the Tudor replica watches. This gave the Rolex Datejust replica a valid and universally accepted identity .People in the limelight stood aloof in the crowd as the owners of an artistic Chopard replica in horology.BulgariBulgari Parentsi, the most accepted ladys model supported by the golden bracelet beautifies the womans wrist. It gives the visual effect of, the famous Bvlgari double ring. When ladies wear the models Ovale, Trika and Lucena on their wrist they get a grand rich look which is unique. With replica movado watches a womans dressing is complete making her something special .The Diagona collection is for the energetic athletes and hardly people.People are very crazy of Rolex Milgauss replica. The Burberry watches industry has come out with very amazing models of original Bulgari. So owning a Bulgari is only a matter of deciding to buy one. It is very difficult to distinguish between the real and the IWC replica. watchesdate.com is the store house of Glashutte replica which keeps their quality in all aspects. So, when you do business with them you are sure of what you are getting. Rolex Sea-Dweller replica has a dark blue dial with red, blue, green, and blue colored sub dials. The Christian Dior replica is capable of displaying the local time, and time in Paris, New York, LA, and Tokyo. The A.Lange & Sohne watches case is 50 mm in diameter. The 440 grade stainless steel used to make the replica Rolex Masterpiece is very strong. The Rolex Datejust II replica comes with a bright blue leather strap. The bezel is decorated with dazzling cubic zircon stones. These are Rolex replica. The sapphire crystal on the Breitling watches glass is scratch proof. There are five crowns for the five time zones. The crown when pulled lets you adjust the time. The second hand of the particular time zone stops to move. You make the time alright and the crown is pushed back in. The second hand starts to move once again. The luminescent time markers and time hands will glow in the dark. You can read the time in the dark too. The replica A.Lange & Sohne are water resistant. You can wear it while swimming and the replica Rolex Daytona will continue to show the correct time. All the crowns are provided with water proof rubber seal.